I've had foot problems since childhood—super-high insteps and arches; wore orthopedic shoes throughout grade school, which naturally made me extremely popular. Not. Here's my grown-up recommendation: Mephisto shoes. You’ll have to search for the good styles; try Salika, Palmyra, and Kimona. I have two pairs of the Lissandra sandals. And here’s a tip: Once you know your size, order them direct from France, where they’re made. Tons more styles and colors, fast shipping to the US (~10 days), and even with shipping charges they're 30 to 40 percent cheaper than in the US